Anyone who is convicted of an offence has an appeal as of right. How to appeal a criminal conviction depends on the Court the original case was heard in. The lowest Court is the District Court, and appeals from the District Court are heard in the Circuit Court. Where the trial of the offence has taken place in either the Circuit Court, the Special Criminal Court (which deals with cases related to organised crime and terrorism) or the Central Criminal Court (the Court dealing with the most serious offences, such as murder), the appeal is to the Court of Appeal.
Scope of Appeal
The scope of an appeal to the Court of Appeal is much narrower than an appeal to the Circuit Court. The Circuit Court will re-hear the case and witnesses may be examined and cross-examined again. Forensic or documentary evidence may also be reconsidered. By contrast, the Court of Appeal does not reconsider the evidence.
Instead, the Court of Appeal considers whether the trial court made any errors, for example, in ruling to admit evidence or exclude evidence. Even where an error is made, it does not automatically mean the conviction is overturned. The Court of Appeal can also consider appeals against sentences. It is important to bear in mind that the Court of Appeal can increase as well as reduce sentences on appeal.
Procedure
There is a narrow timeframe in which to appeal: 10 days where appealing from the District Court and 28 days in all other cases. The Court of Appeal requires the grounds setting out the basis for the appeal to be filed before the trial transcripts are released. If you qualify for free legal aid, you will not be charged for the transcript. Otherwise, you will need to pay fees to cover the costs of transcribing.
If you have decided to change solicitor for the appeal (which you are entitled to do), the new solicitor must be provided a copy of the previous solicitor’s file, unless the solicitor is entitled to withhold the file on account of unpaid fees (called exercising a lien).
At the hearing of the appeal, Counsel for both the convicted person and the State will address the Court of Appeal, which sits with three judges. A written judgment will be delivered, and will be published online. There is no further appeal, unless the Supreme Court decides to hear the case on grounds that a point of general public importance is raised or it is in the interests of justice to do so.
The above is a general commentary on the law and does not constitute legal advice for your particular circumstances.
