Under section 123 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2004 (“the 2004 Act”), a party (in practice normally either the landlord or the tenant) can appeal a decision of a Tribunal of the Residential Tenancies Board (“RTB”) to the High Court. It is important to understand what this means before proceeding.
A point of law only
You cannot appeal the outcome of an RTB Tribunal simply because you disagree with it or feel it was unfair. The RTB deals with many thousands of cases, and there will frequently be cases where a different decision-maker would have made a different decision. When a decision of an adjudicator is appealed to the Tribunal, the case can be re-argued, and new evidence can be submitted. It is very different in the High Court. The test is whether the decision was lawfully made or contained an error in how the law was applied.
As the Court will not have seen witnesses give evidence, it will not overturn a Tribunal’s finding on the facts, provided the decision was reached lawfully. In deciding whether the Tribunal reached its decision lawfully, the Court is not completely excluded from looking at the facts of the case. The Court may, for example, consider whether evidence was excluded for no valid reason, or whether the Tribunal reached a decision that had no evidence to support it. This is a high threshold.
21-day deadline
There is a deadline of 21 days (i.e., three weeks) to appeal a decision of the RTB Tribunal. This is a very short timeframe, and therefore it is essential that you move quickly if you wish to appeal. It is important to note that the 21-day deadline is counted from when the decision was issued by the RTB, not the date on which you received it.
Preparing the appeal is a very formal legal process, in contrast to the more informal procedures of the RTB. A Notice of Motion must be prepared and filed in the Central Office of the High Court along with an Affidavit (sworn document). Stamp duty also needs to be paid.
Status of matters while the case is ongoing
While the appeal is ongoing, the Determination Order of the RTB will be suspended from coming into effect. This means that it cannot be enforced until the Court makes its decision. The Court may decide to uphold the Order, or may direct the RTB to cancel or vary the Order. In some cases, the Court may order the case to be remitted (sent back) to the RTB for a new decision.
Risks
Like any legal process, an appeal to the High Court carries risks. What these risks are will depend on the case. One of the most serious risks is that if you are unsuccessful, an order for legal costs may be made against you. Whether proceeding with an appeal is worth the risks is something your solicitor can advise on, but it will be your decision.
The above is a general commentary on the law and does not constitute legal advice for your particular circumstances.
